REVIEW AND ANALYSIS 43 heritage can be commercially attractive, but hotel use is particularly sensitive to location and the quality of the surrounding neighbourhood. Furthermore, Bodmin was a roofless ruin when the prison was brought back into use, justifying a greater degree of intervention than might otherwise have been possible. HMP Oxford occupies part of the site of Oxford Castle, itself founded by William the Conqueror in 1071. The main prison buildings date from around 1870, though the site had functioned as a county gaol since the 18th century with the remains of older fabric still embedded within it. The prison closed in 1996, returned to Oxfordshire County Council, and stood vacant for a decade while its future was debated. The conversion, led by the Trevor Osborne Property Group with funding that included a £3.8 million Heritage Lottery Fund grant, resulted in the Malmaison hotel opening in 2006. The wider Oxford Castle site was simultaneously redeveloped as a visitor attraction. The conversion retained much of the most significant fabric, with heavy iron cell doors, wrought-iron landing balustrades, and the radiating atrium structure of the main wing becoming the defining aesthetic of the hotel. The key intervention that made hotel use feasible was the amalgamation of cells. Each hotel room was formed from two original cells knocked together, doubling the floor area and partially removing internal partition walls. New windows were inserted below the historic stone string courses to improve natural light to bedrooms, carefully positioned so as not to disturb the original window openings above. The execution suite was considered unsuitable for hotel bedrooms and was converted to offices. Later twentiethcentury service and workshop buildings of lesser significance were removed, allowing the earlier structure to read more clearly. TAI KWUN, HONG KONG For heritage professionals grappling with redundant prisons in the UK, the transformation of the former Central Police Station compound in Hong Kong into a museum and cultural centre may offer some inspiration. Now known as Tai Kwun, meaning ‘Big Station’ in Cantonese, the site had been continuously associated with law enforcement and incarceration since Britain established its colony in 1841. Victoria Gaol, said to be the first Western building of durable construction in Hong Kong, was completed in 1842, but it soon became overcrowded. Reconstruction of a new prison in granite and brick was completed in 1862, using a half-radial Glass ‘waiting pavilions’ – an art installation by Alicja Kwade installed in the prison compound in 2024, with Herzog & de Meuron’s art gallery for contemporary art beyond (Photo: Jonathan Taylor) The former prison compound of Victoria Gaol after refurbishment and adaptation: the space is popular with locals and visitors from across the world, including Europe and mainland China (Photo: Jonathan Taylor) plan following British prison design principles. Its three cell blocks and two diagonal wings allowed for European and Chinese prisoners to be confined separately. Construction of the Central Police Station followed in 1864, and the complex was subsequently expanded through the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The surviving fabric spans nearly 170 years of civic history across 16 buildings, with the three principal components — the Central Police Station, the Central Magistracy and Victoria Prison — declared monuments in 1995 under Hong Kong’s Antiquities and
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjgyMjA=